The Morning Card — September 19, 2026

The analyst's record: 60–53 since 2026-09-01. Every pick grades in public.

Last night

We finished 5-3 for +0.9u, a modestly profitable night and not a moment for gloating. Our best result was Gerrit Cole Over 4.5 Ks (actual 6); our worst miss was Andrew Sears Over 3.5 Ks (actual 0).

Gerrit Cole — Over 4.5 Ks (-119): WON
Tyler Phillips — Under 3.5 Ks (-122): WON
Dustin May — Under 5.5 Ks (-124): WON
Mason Barnett — Over 2.5 Ks (-125): WON
Chase Burns — Over 3.5 Ks (-149): WON
Kyle Leahy — Over 2.5 Ks (-139): LOST
Ranger Suarez — Under 4.5 Ks (-134): LOST
Andrew Sears — Over 3.5 Ks (-146): LOST

Tonight

15 games on the slate — the marquee: Tigers @ Sox at 2026-09-19T18:10:00.0000000+00:00.

Sean Burke's 9.7 K/9 against a Tigers lineup that whiffs at a 23% clip is the matchup's defining edge — the game shapes up as a strikeout duel where starter dominance could swing the outcome. Books list the Sox the favorite at about -134 while the total sits at 8.3, signaling expectations for a modest-scoring contest. Rate Field plays pitcher-friendly (-7% runs vs average) and both bullpens have been worked recently, which only amplifies the value of starter punchouts tonight.

Watch list

Mariners @ Rockies — Jose Quintana has dominated Seattle Mariners — .194 BAA with a 29% strikeout rate over 190 plate appearances across 5 seasons.

More cards

← September 18, 2026 September 20, 2026 →

Nov 3 · Nov 2 · Nov 1 · Oct 31 · Oct 30 · Oct 29 · Oct 28 · Oct 27 · Oct 26 · Oct 25